View the Current In-Store Menu

Printable Winter Seasonal Menu
Winter Menu – Available January & February 2025
Spring Menu – Available March thru May 2025

Things to Know:
1. We do not use preservatives so our products have a shorter shelf life.
2. Our cupcakes should be eaten at room temperature. They are often refrigerated in store for freshness.
3. We offer a small selection of gluten free and vegan products daily.
4. We are not a nut free facility.

View All Seasonal Menus

We rotate our in-store menu seasonally to offer a variety of flavors throughout the year.

Please call to check for availability. Most next or same day orders must be from the seasonal menu.

View Valentine’s Day Order Menu

View St. Patrick’s Day Specials

Pre order deadline is March 14.
Specials will be available in store the weeks surrounding March 17.

View Easter Order Menu

Order Deadline is April 15.
Select Easter specials will be available in store.

Please note that graduation order slots fill quickly. Must order 1 week in advance at minimum. Custom grad orders must be placed at least 2-3 weeks in advance.  To place an order, submit and online request, email us at orders@theluckycupcakecompany.com, or call the shop at 267-544-5912. Payment due at time of order. **We will accommodate allergies as much as possible.

Graduation Items

Must order 1 week in advance at minimum. Custom orders must be placed at least 2-3 weeks in advance. To place an order call the shop at 267-544-5912, email, or order online. Payment due at time of order. **We will accommodate allergies as much as possible.

Christening, Baptism, Communion Items

Ordering for a small birthday, graduation, or special event celebration? Make your order a bundle! Includes a Lucky Cupcake tote bag, balloons, and a card for the person you are celebrating. Price varies based on final order.

We have over 100 different cupcake flavors!

View all Cupcake Flavors
View Seasonal In-Store Flavors

Gluten Free, Vegan, and other allergy free options are available for select flavors.

View all Cupcake Flavors

Things to Know:
1. All Custom Orders should be placed at least 2 weeks in advance.
2. We require non-refundable deposits on all custom orders.
3. Final cupcake pricing depends on quantity, flavor, and finish.
4. Custom Cupcakes require a 6 cupcake minimum of one cupcake flavor.
5. When you pick up your order, your cupcakes will be refrigerated. Please serve and eat your cupcakes at room temperature.
6. Select Gluten Free, Vegan, and other allergy free options are available for select flavors.

We have over 100 different cupcake flavors that can also be made as cakes.

View All Cake Flavors
View Seasonal In-Store Cupcake/Cake Flavors

Gluten Free, Vegan, and other allergy free options are available for select flavors.

View All Cake Flavors

Things to Know:
1. All Custom Orders should be placed at least 2 weeks in advance.
2. We require non-refundable deposits on all custom orders.
3. Final cake pricing depends on cake size, flavor, and finish.
4. When you pick up your order, your cake will be refrigerated. Please serve and eat your cake at room temperature.
5. Gluten Free, Vegan, and other allergy free options are available for select flavors.

These flavors can only be made as cakes.

Lemon Mascarpone Vanilla sponge cake layered with lemon cream and lemon mascarpone icing, finished with lemon mascarpone icing

Chocolate Beast Moist, flourless chocolate torte dusted with powdered sugar (cannot be made as a tiered cake)

Lemon Cheesecake Cake Lemon cake layer, NY cheesecake layer, , Lemon mousse layer, lemon cake layer finished in a light lemon buttercream

Chocolate Cheesecake Cake Chocolate cake layer, NY Cheesecakes, Chocolate Mousse layer, Chocolate Cake Layer, finished in chocolate buttercream and drip in chocolate glaze.

Red Velvet Cheesecake Cake Red velvet cake layer, NY cheesecake layer, cinnamon cream cheese layer, red velvet cake layer finished in vanilla buttercream.

Chocolate Strawberry Cheesecake Two layers chocolate cake with one layer NY cheesecake and fresh strawberries in between the layers with optional finishes

Neapolitan one layer each vanilla, chocolate, and red velvet cake, filled with cinnamon cream cheese, topped with vanilla, chocolate and pink vanilla buttercream

Pumpkin Neapolitan one layer each vanilla, chocolate, and pumpkin spice cake, filled with cinnamon cream cheese, topped with vanilla, chocolate and pumpkin buttercream

Italian Rum Cake Vanilla cake soaked with rum syrup, filled with one layer each vanilla and chocolate pastry creams, finished with vanilla buttercream and toasted pistachios or walnuts (chocolate drip finish optional)

What is it?
A layer of cake with scoop of mousse, covered in chocolate.

View Seasonal In-Store Flavors

All Mousse Bomb Flavors:
Coconut, Chocolate, Peanut Butter, Chocolate Strawberry, Chocolate Raspberry, Chocolate Espresso, Strawberry Coconut

View Seasonal In-Store Flavors

All Cheesecake Flavors:
New York, Hot Chocolate, Lemon, Key Lime Swirl, Caramel Apple, Strawberry, Peach, Pumpkin

Order Sizes:
Individual, Large Cheesecake 8″, 10″

What is it?
A layer of cake or similar, topped with cheesecake and topping, all in a double sized cupcake wrapper.

View Seasonal In-Store Flavors

All Double Cheesecake Flavors:
White Chocolate Raspberry, Peanut Butter Brownie*, Oreo, S’mores, Pumpkin Swirl, Oreo Peppermint, Birthday Cake, Key Lime Swirl, Strawberry Shortcake, Lemon Blueberry

Gluten Free, Vegan, and other allergy free options are available for select flavors.

What is it?
Depending on the flavor, pie or cheesecake baked into a cake.

View Seasonal In-Store Flavors
**Pie & Cheesecake Cakes are typically not available in-store all year long.

All Pie Cake & Cheesecake Cake Flavors:
Pumpkin Pie Cake, Apple Pie Cake, Chocolate Pecan Pie Cake, Red Velvet Cheesecake Layer Cake, Lemon Blueberry Cheesecake Layer Cake

Order Sizes:
Seasonally available slices, Half 10″, or Whole 10″

View Seasonal In-Store Flavors

All Tart Flavors:
Caramel Pretzel Nutella, S’mores, Lemon Meringue, Fresh Fruit, Key Lime, S’mores, Salted Nut, Caramel Cranberry Orange, Strawberry, Blueberry, Caramel Apple

Order Sizes:
Individual 4″, Large Tart 8″, 10″, or 12″

A specialty item. Please inquire about availability.

View Seasonal In-Store Flavors

All Cake Pop Flavors:
Vanilla, Chocolate, Red Velvet

Order Size:
Order by the dozen, custom finishes available.

Cannoli are often available by order only. They are sometimes an in-store special. Inquire about availability.

Inquire about availability:
Mini cupcakes
Mini Cheesecakes
Mini Tarts
Mini Mousse Bombs
Cake Pops
Mousse Cups
Mini Cannoli

Available by order only. We offer a wide selection of options for dessert trays.

Ordering:
Inquire for item selection, sizes, and final pricing.

View Seasonal In-Store Flavors

All Scone Flavors:
Caramel Toffee, Cranberry Orange, Lemon Blueberry, Chocolate Chip, Apple Strudel, Pumpkin Praline, Apple Strudel, Gingerbread, Apple Cranberry, Blackberry Rosemary, Caramel Apple, Strawberry Chocolate Chip, Strawberries & Cream, Peaches n’ Cream, Peach Praline, Vanilla Bean

Ordering:
Please inquire about sizes and final pricing.

View Seasonal In-Store Flavors

All Muffin Flavors:
Blueberry Crumb, Blueberry Cheesecake, Banana Chocolate Chip, Lemon Crumb, Apple Crumb, Pumpkin Chocolate Chip Cheesecake, Cranberry Crumb, Chocolate Chip Cheesecake, Banana Chocolate Chip Cheesecake, Banana Nut, Chocolate Chip, Strawberry Crumb, Peach Crumb, Apple Cheesecake, Peach Cheesecake

Ordering:
Please inquire about sizes and final pricing.

View Seasonal In-Store Flavors

All Crumb Cake Flavors:
Plain, Strawberry, Blueberry, Pumpkin, Cinnamon Swirl, Peach, Apple

Ordering:
Inquire about size and pricing options.

View Seasonal In-Store Flavors

All Bar Flavors:
Almond Cranberry, Chocolate Pecan, Cranberry Walnut, Lemon, Fudge Brownie, Buttercake, Almond Blueberry, Caramelita, Key Lime, Dirty Brownie, Gingerbread Brownie, S’mores, Salted Nut, Strawberry Crumb bar

Gluten Free, Vegan, and other allergy free options are available for select flavors.

Ordering:
Please inquire about sizes and final pricing.

Assorted Flavors are available most weekends in-store.
Please inquire about custom donut orders.
Available Donuts: Regular Specialty, & Filled

View Seasonal In-Store Flavors

All Croissant & Twist Flavors:
Plain Croissant, Assorted Savory Croissants, Bacon Twists, Assorted Fruit Twists

Ordering:
Please inquire about sizes and final pricing.

View Seasonal In-Store Flavors

All Bread Pudding Flavors:
Regular, Bourbon Peach Cobbler, Seasonal Specialty Flavors

Ordering:
Please inquire about sizes and final pricing.

View Seasonal In-Store Flavors

All Fruit Pie Flavors (Crumb, Lattice, or Double Crust):
Apple, Blueberry, Strawberry, Cherry, Peach, Mix Berry, Strawberry Rhubarb

All Specialty Pie Flavors:
Cannoli, Key Lime, Pecan, Chocolate Pecan, Pumpkin, Lemon Meringue, Coconut Cream

Gluten Free, Vegan, and other allergy free options are available for select flavors.

Order Sizes:
4″ or 9″

Often available by order only, we carry a variety of pastry pan items.

Pastry Pan Items:
Crumb Cakes, Buttercakes, Cobblers, Crisps

Gluten Free, Vegan and other allergy free options are available for select items and flavors.

Order Sizes:
8×8 or 9×13

Available by order only. We offer a wide selection of options for brunch trays, pastry trays, and coffee boxes.

Ordering:
Inquire for item selection, sizes, and final pricing.

Gingerbread and Various decorated cookies are available year-round.

Available Decorated Cookies:
Gingerbread, Assorted Sugar Cookies

Ordering:
Seasonal or Custom Finishes (including edible images) are available. Inquire for pricing and quantity requirements.

View Seasonal In-Store Flavors

All Regular Cookie Flavors:
Sugar, Chocolate Chip, Oatmeal Raisin, Peanut Butter, Double Chocolate, Gingersnap, Snickerdoodle, Lemon, White Chocolate Macadamia Nut, Double Chocolate Peppermint, Pumpkin Chocolate Chip, Toasted Coconut White Chocolate, Oatmeal Strawberry, Oatmeal Blueberry, Oatmeal Peach, Oatmeal Cranberry

Order Sizes:
Seasonal cookies can be ordered by assorted dozen
Non – seasonal cookies must be ordered by a dozen per flavor.
Assorted Cookie Boxes and Cookie Trays are available.

Usually available by order only.

Specialty Cookie Flavors:
Cookie Pops, Linzer, Kiffle, Snowball

Order Sizes:
Non – seasonal cookies must be ordered by a dozen per flavor.
Assorted Cookie Boxes and Cookie Trays are available.

What is it?
Edible cookie dough sandwiched between Oreo wafers.

Available Flavors:
Assorted flavors are available through out the year. Inquire about availability.

Gluten Free, Vegan, and other allergy free options are available for select flavors.

Ordering:
Inquire about flavors, order minimums, and final pricing.

Macarons are often available by order only. They are sometimes an in-store special. Inquire about availability.

View Seasonal In-Store Flavors

All Biscotti Flavors:
Almond, Cranberry Almond, Double Chocolate, Gingerbread, Lemon Poppy, Pumpkin

Ordering:
Please inquire about flavor, order minimums and final pricing.

Housemade Granola

Housemade Hot Cocoa Jars

Retail Freezer Items
Grab a few of our ready to bake, retail freezer items!  Products are frozen and packaged with simple “how to” guide so you can enjoy your Lucy Cupcake favorites fresh from your oven! Item and flavor availability varies seasonally.

Available Products: Scones, Cookie Dough, Muffins

Toggle content goes here, click edit button to change this text.

Toggle content goes here, click edit button to change this text.

Lucky Cupcake Clothing
Assorted styles of baby, kids, and adult items and designs. Please inquire for available styles and size options.

Pink and Grey Original Style
Adult & Kid – Hoodie & Short Sleeve Options

Baby & Maternity
Assorted Lucky Cupcake Onesies and Bibs
“I Love My Lucky Cupcake in the Oven” Maternity Shirt

Other
Aprons – Regular & Kid Size
Assorted Hats

Blue Snowflake Style
Adult & Kids – Hoodies

Fly Eagles Fly! Style
Adult & Kids – Hoodies & Short Sleeve Options

I Love Lucky Cupcake Style
Adult – Long Sleeve Options

Feeling Lucky? Style
Adult – Crew Neck Sweatshirts & Short Sleeve Shirts

Happy Fall Y’all! Style
Adult – Brown Long or Short Sleeve
Kids – Yellow Short Sleeve

Gingerbread Style
Adult & Kids – Hoodies & Short Sleeve Options

Grinch Style
Adult & Kids – Hoodies
Baby – Onesies

Lucky Cupcake Campfire Mugs
Available seasonally – black and white styles

We do not use preservatives in our products.

We can only ship certain items within select time frames for freshness.

Shipping and Handling fees will be applied to your order and are varied based on delivery address.

Delivery delays are out of our control.

Muffins
Assorted Seasonal Flavors

Scones
Assorted Seasonal Flavors

Croissants
Plain, Assorted Seasonal Filled, & Bacon Twists

8×8 Crumb Cake
Assorted Seasonal Flavors

8×8 Butter Cake
Plain flavor available for shipping.

House Made Granola
1lb or 2lb Bags Available.
Assorted Seasonal Flavors.

Large Cookie 12 Pack
Assorted seasonal flavors, including Peanut Butter unless specified.

Decorated Sugar Cookies
Assorted seasonal shapes/decor unless specified.
Custom shapes/decor may increase price.

Macarons
Assorted seasonal flavors unless specified.
Macarons must be shipped via overnight shipping.

Stuffed Cookies 
Edible cookie dough sandwiched between two cookies.
Assorted seasonal flavors available.

Cookie Cakes
Assorted seasonal flavors.
Available in Small, Medium or Large.

Lucky Cupcake Company Gift Cards
Please indicate dollar amount you would like the card for. 

Sweet Shopper Tote Bag
Reusable grocery bag with seasonal Lucky Cupcake design

Lucky Cupcake Clothing
Assorted styles of baby, kids, and adult items and designs. Please inquire for options.

Group & Troop Organizers – Interested in working with The Lucky Cupcake for your next fundraiser? Please contact our office staff via email at office@theluckycupcakecompany.com.

Group & Troop Members – If your group or troop has already organized an event our office staff, please click on your group’s tab on the Group Order Submission page for place your order**

For Tour Group Staff/Organizers – Interested in on of our decorating events for your tour guests while in the village? Please contact our office staff via email at office@theluckycupcakecompany.com.

For Tour Group Members – If your tour group has already organized an event our office staff, please go to our Group Order Submission page and select the Village Bus Tour Group tab to submit your event order request.

General donation requests should be emailed directly to office@theluckycupcakecompany.com.