Thanksgiving Order Menu
Order deadline is November 20. All orders must be picked up by November 25. The bakery is closed November 26. To place an order or check in store availability, please call the shop at 267-544-5912, email, or order online.
Payment due at time of order.
**We will accommodate allergies as much as possible. Select gluten free or vegan options available by pre-order only.
Fall Mini Cupcake 12 Pack
Includes Apple Pie, Pumpkin Spice, Oreo, Boston Cream, Plain Jane and Triple Chocolate cupcakes with fall décor.
$24.00 per Dozen
Mini Dessert Trays
Includes Assorted Fall Seasonal Flavors of:
Mini Bars, Cake Pops, Mini Cupcakes, & Mini Tarts
**6 Person minimum for tray assembly
Pies (9”)
Pumpkin $16.50
Pumpkin Crumb $18.50
Pecan $24.50
Apple Crumb $22.50
Apple Double Crust $24.50
Cherry Crumb $22.50
Cherry Double Crust $24.50
Spiced Peach Crumb $22.50
Spiced Peach Double Crust $24.50
Chocolate Silk $24.50
Cranberry Apple Streusel $22.50
Coconut Cream $24.50
Banana Cream $24.50
Lemon Meringue $24.50
Key Lime $24.50
Sweet Potato $18.50
Peanut Butter $24.50
** Select Gluten free or vegan pie flavors available by pre-order only for an additional cost.**
Pumpkin Rolls
Regular $15.00
Caramel Pecan $20.00
8” Tarts
Cranberry Almond $22.50
Chocolate Pecan $22.50
S’mores $22.50
Large Cheesecakes
New York 6” $35.00, 8” $45.00
S’mores 6” $35.00, 8” $45.00
Pumpkin 6” $35.00, 8” $45.00
10” Pie Cakes
A pie, baked into a cake. Two desserts in one!
Apple Full Cake$75.00, Half Cake $40.00
Pumpkin Full Cake$75.00, Half Cake $40.00
Apple Dumpling 4 Pack $28.00
with choice of caramel, custard, or glaze
Fall Cookie Trays
Assorted fall flavors and decorations
Small (2 dozen cookies) $30.00
Medium (3-3.5 dozen cookies) $45.00
Large (4.5-5 dozen cookies) $65.00
Thanksgiving Cookie Activity Kits
Includes: Shaped seasonal sugar cookies and gingerbread cookies, royal icing, decorations, how-to
** Activity kit available by pre-order only
Box for 4: $25.00
Box for 8: $45.00